Governor Greatly Concerned by Legislature’s Errors

Problems with legislation considered during last week’s Special Session were largely due to errors made at the Senate.

In a letter sent Monday to Senate President Myron D. Jackson, Governor Kenneth E. Mapp responded to concerns raised on the Senate floor, and later reported in the media, that the bills sent to the Legislature could not be acted on as a result of errors and contradictions. Governor Mapp expressed concern that the proposed bills prepared by Government House for the May 10, 2017 Special Session of the 32nd Legislature were not the same bills that were considered by the body.

Read the Governor’s Letter to the Legislature

Government House Chief Legal Counsel Emile Henderson compared the bills that Governor Mapp transmitted to the Legislature against the bills that were introduced on the Senate floor on May 10.

“To my chagrin, the proposed bills prepared by Government House and submitted to the 32nd Legislature of the Virgin Islands were not the bills before the Legislature,” Governor Mapp remarked. “What is even more troubling is that the bills the Legislature numbered, authored as ‘Request of the Governor’ and subsequently voted to send to committees were not the proposals I sent to you and each member of the Legislature.”

The review by the Chief Legal Counsel and his staff found that the bills introduced at the Special Session contained errors, technical and substantive, and some contained considerable contradictions to what was sent to the Legislature for consideration. Further review found that these errors and omissions occurred in the Office of the Legislature’s Legal Counsel.

“The bills I submitted in my special call and the bills that were introduced and debated on the Senate floor were significantly different bills,” the Governor wrote. “The question now is: Are the bills which have been sent to the legislative committees legally there? These bills or proposals are not my bills. The bills voted on by the Senate on May 10, 2017, are substantively different than the proposals I transmitted to the Legislature.”

Governor Mapp encouraged the Senate President to launch a review at the Senate, compare the drafts submitted by Government House to him and each Member of the Senate, to what was considered on the Senate floor and ultimately acted upon.

“Mr. President, this is a serious matter and this should not happen again. These errors substantially changed the content of or excluded language contained in my original proposals.  The bills prepared by the Legislature’s Legal Counsel’s office now require extensive corrections before they can even be considered by the committees to which they were sent.  Am I required to call another special session and submit my original submission of proposed bills for proper action by the Senate?” he asked.

The Governor acknowledged his staff had made mistakes of their own, to include an incorrect bill summary, however, none of these controverted the intent of the legislation. He said Government House will review its protocols.

“I regret this error and I assure you that there was no ‘trickery’ involved in this oversight. The testimony of my financial team made clear the intent of the appropriation request and acknowledged the error,” he wrote.

Governor Mapp asked for recommendations from the Senate President on how to deal with the issue of the 32nd Legislature voting to transmit the Special Session bills to committees that were not the original legislation as submitted by the Governor.